Subject	What's up with Edmunds values vs Nada
Posted by	jamil on December 17, 2008 at 10:41 AM
	This message has been viewed 375 times.
Message	I was trying to appraise my car and was surprised at the disparity between Nada bluebook vs Edmunds. If anything I thought the edmunds value would be higher. Here is how they compared: 1991 twinturbo with 145000 miles in avg condition: Nada: avg trade in=$4425, clean retail=$6700 Edmunds: avg trade in =$997, clean retail=$2600. 3X-4X difference. Wow.
Follow Ups	What's up with Edmunds values vs Nada - jamil 10:41:16 12/17/08 They both suck and you shouldn't go by their value. (n/m) - John@Z1 10:44:13 12/17/08 You got to go with some standard value, you can't make up (n/m) - jamil 10:50:17 12/17/08 NADA and KBB and Black Book are good starting values - BigTDogg (MA) 10:52:11 12/17/08 Please reconcile your statements, "NADA and KBB and... - 240Z FeO2 11:17:38 12/17/08 Starting point. That plus a premium for a clean car - BigTDogg (MA) 12:17:12 12/17/08 So NADA and like blue books represent values of the - 240Z FeO2 12:42:06 12/17/08 That's what I've found since I started with Zs. - BigTDogg (MA) 12:44:31 12/17/08 Ditto on the rarity. It took me over 6 months to find my car - 240Z FeO2 13:17:13 12/17/08 How much more expensive is a stated value policy? (n/m) - rojoloco (San Diego) 15:43:01 12/17/08 Both times I inquired about stated value insurance the - 240Z FeO2 18:30:47 12/17/08 I currently have Progressive on both my vehicles. - rojoloco (San Diego) 19:25:30 12/17/08 I don't know, but suspect stated value policies are written - 240Z FeO2 19:48:26 12/17/08 And yet all the crybabies on here - ENVYMYZ 11:49:50 12/17/08 $8-9k, assuming stock and fairly clean. imo - SuparexTT 11:13:58 12/17/08 I just ran values on an Integra, Edmunds was high... - whitepearl 11:30:16 12/17/08 Those values make me want to slit my wrists. (n/m) - Inzane 11:42:57 12/17/08 Jay, put the knife down... slowly... Don't worry. - MixManMash 11:55:03 12/17/08 I dont like those "estimates" - Drk93TT 12:16:08 12/17/08 I'd never use ebay as a price guide - aliaZ 12:25:09 12/17/08 well, they still sell for an actual price. - Drk93TT 16:17:09 12/17/08 only lazy or desperate people sell mint cars on ebay - AntiHero 16:25:47 12/17/08 yep (n/m) - aliaZ 16:27:29 12/17/08 I would think these 'standardized' estimates would be taking - jamil 12:40:34 12/17/08 KBB is gauged for dealers, Edmunds for consumers. - Scotts94z32 12:46:51 12/17/08 Good advice! (n/m) - Piranha(AZ) 12:56:06 12/17/08 The black book is nice to look at too. - rojoloco (San Diego) 15:45:27 12/17/08 Yup. Even though I'm in sales myself, I can not STAND car - ENVYMYZ 16:48:51 12/17/08 x2. With the exception of a few that I have run across. (n/m) - MixManMash 17:36:19 12/17/08 no market price? - tyler@boostpro.net 22:53:17 12/17/08
Post a Followup	You cannot reply to this message because you are not logged in.